CARI Malay Forums

 Forgot Pass?
 Register

Facebook Login

Login by Facebook

Forum : Gosip |  Hiburan |  Isu Semasa & Politik |  Peristiwa |  Lawak & Santai |  Sukan |  Informasi |  Kesihatan |  Soal Jawab Agama |  Negeri & Negara
Wanita & Lelaki |  Cinta & Perhubungan |  Belia & Pengetahuan |  Komputer & Internet |  Hobi |  Buku & Penulisan |  Koleksi Gambar
English Channel |  தமிழ் மக்கள் |  Jual/Beli |  Maklum Balas |  CARI Rasmi |  Cari Contest
"Friday 22 Aug-National Mourning Day : Mourning For MH17 Victims......."
12Next
Return Post new threads
Show: 5930|Reply: 25

Hang Tuah

[Copy link]

Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11

Post on 12-10-2010 10:09 PM |All posts

To get Malaysia's most comprehensive information, news, life sharing here!
Register as a CARI member NOW!

Register Login or Facebook Login

Hai Forummers semua, dalam aku googling, terbaca blog ini yang menceritakan tentang Sejarah Hang Tuah.Mari kita buat komentar berkaitaan Teori yang dilontarkan oleh penulis ini.

HANG TUAH
Sumber: http://mthago.wordpress.com/2010/10/11/hang-tuah/


Hang Tuah was synonymous with bravery and heroism. He was a Malay legend and a symbol of obedience without question to the Sultan. Hang Tuah had served the Sultan as Laksamana and had led many expeditions outside Malacca as ambassador to the Sultan of Malacca. He was very loyal to the Sultan and was willing to take the order of the Sultan even to the extent of killing his most trusted and loving companion Hang Jebat. Hang Tuah was the symbol of loyalty. Loyalty is a much needed quality in any establishment. The stories of Hang Tuah have been narrated over and over again throughout the ages and the stories have sometimes become a myth rather than a true historical fact. Although some stories about Hang Tuah do not seem to be logical but they are continually being narrated over the generations until today. These stories were written in our history books and are being read to our children. Stories about Hang Tuah have also been made into a movie and a theater and were watched by all of us from time to time. Are all the stories about Hang Tuah plain truth or mixed with lies? Are our historians making any research on the many stories about Hang Tuah? We should not write any lies and spreading lies about Hang Tuah. Our many generations to come will read whatever written in our history books. We should only write the truth and not lies. In case we are not certain about the truthiness of certain stories , then we should not write that particular stories in our history books. Whatever written in our history books should be authentic and proven by research and plain logic.

I have been many times to Malacca but during my recent visit to Malacca I was somehow became interested with the history of Malacca. I wanted to know about a great Malay warrior, known as Laksamana Hang Tuah. I was told that Hang Tuah had a well in Kampong Duyung, the village that Hang Tuah was supposed to be born. I went to the village and visited the well. Upon entering the village I saw a mosques by the name of Hang Tuah Mosques and then I saw a Chinese grave yard but there was no Chinese living in the village. Where have all the Chinese gone? There are two possibilities, either all the Chinese have converted to Islam and became Muslims or the Chinese have migrated somewhere else. It was possible that Hang Tuah was a Chinese who can no longer speak Chinese like the Chinese baba and nyoya and has adopted Malay cultures. Hang Tuah was employed by the Sultan to be a Laksamana and the title Hang was given to him because he was a warrior. The word Tuah could have come from the two Chinese words, Tou and Ah and was pronounced by the Malays as Tuah. Hang Tuah was the greatest Laksamana of the Sultan of Malacca and he had served all the five renowned Sultans of Malacca before Malacca was taken over by the Portuguese. In my opinion the stories about the well of Hang Tuah is only a legend. There is no scientific study to prove that the well was built and used by Hang Tuah. The legends associated with the well are not supposed to be told or written anywhere, as by doing so, we are only spreading lies about Hang Tuah to the people. As a great warrior, having a well was not an object of pride, whereas Hang Tuah should be better associated with a Kris or any other weapons of his time.

Where is the grave of Hang Tuah? Some said that Hang Tuah just disappeared and thus has no grave. Some said that Hang Tuahs grave is in Tanjong Kling. I went to Tanjong Kling to see the grave. I was curious to know whether the grave that has been labeled as Hang Tuahs grave was truly belong to Hang Tuah or actually belong to someone else. Why Hang Tuah, who was a noble and a warrior should be buried in Kampong Kling, a place far from the administrative centre of Malacca. When Malacca was taken over by the Portuguese, where Hang Tuah was living? Could Hang Tuah being living in an Indian village? Tanjong Kling was the village of the Indians and Indians during those times were known as Kling. When I saw the grave, I knew it has no characteristic of either a Malay or a Chinese grave. The grave has the characteristics of an Indian grave. The grave is long and it looks similar to the grave in Pulau Besar, Malacca. In my opinion the grave belongs to an Indian Muslim who had come to Malacca to preach Islam and is not Hang Tuahs grave. Hang Tuah must had been buried in an area very closed to the administrative centre of Malacca and a possible site could be in Kampong Hulu. To prove whether Hang Tuah was a Muslim or not, requires other studies to verify. Hang Tuah could had been a non-Muslim but later on converted to Islam and this is another area that Malaysian historians can research.

The Chinese had come and live in Malaysia since the time of the Sultanates of Malacca. Are those generations of the Chinese that had lived since those ancient times Bumiputra or non-Bumiputra? Are the descendants of Hang Tuah Bumiputra?  Malays are Bumiputra and Malays are defined as those who can speak Malay, is a Muslim and has adopted Malay cultures. Kadazans and Ibans are also Bumiputra but a Chinese like the descendent of Hang Tuah and Hang Jebat is not a Bumiputra. A Kadazan or an Iban is not a Muslim and does not adopt a Malay culture but he or she is still regarded as a Bumiputra because their ancestors had come to live in Sabah or Sarawak hundreds of years ago. In my opinion we have to redefine what Bumiputra and non-Bumiputra are and our definitions must be fair and logical. There are many who are not truly Malay but are being regarded as Malays. They are considered as Malays because they speak Malay language, they are Muslims by birth and they adopt Malay cultures. As I wrote in my previous article about the origin of the Malay people, the Javanese, Achiness and Bugis people are not Malay people but are being regarded as Malays because they speak Malay language and they practice Islam. The real Malay people as I have hypothesized is one of the tribes of Bani Israel who had migrated from the Mediterranean region to this part of the world thousands of years ago.

Dr. Nasoha Saabin
October 2010
Dean of Faculty of Optometry
International University College of Technology Twintech
Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia


:&
Reply

Props Report

Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11

Post on 13-10-2010 11:12 AM |All posts
Post Last Edit by capiloton at 13-10-2010 11:15

hahahaha..

tak abih2 nak mencinakan hang tuah..
ni mesti geng2 si mamak shahabudin jalil..  

artikel ni berbau politik..
kalo betoi nak citer pasal sejarah, apa pasal nak ungkit isu bumiputra?
jangan ada yg tolol percaya semata2 sebab dia ada title doktor..
YM - neo05080201
Reply

Props Report

Rank: 10Rank: 10Rank: 10

Post on 13-10-2010 11:31 AM |All posts
Hahahaha.... kalau Hang Tuah tu Cina memang seorang Cina yang begitu taat kepada Sultan Melayu sehingga sanggup bunuh saudara sebangsanya sendiri Hang Jebat.  Memang respectlah Hang Tuah nii... Patut menjadi lambang dan ikon 1Malaysia.
Reply

Props Report

Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11

Post on 13-10-2010 11:58 AM |All posts
itulah
aku pening jgak baca
tu yg nak dengau pendapat semua
:&
Reply

Props Report

Rank: 8Rank: 8

Post on 13-10-2010 12:01 PM |All posts
aku pun rasa ada unsur2 politik kat artikel ni.....tak pasal2 nak citer pasal bumiputera plak...org2 mcm ni la yg nak wat Malaysia kacau bilau......
Reply

Props Report

Moderator

Weapon X

Rank: 22Rank: 22Rank: 22Rank: 22Rank: 22Rank: 22

Moderator

Post on 13-10-2010 12:07 PM |All posts
hang hang yang kat belah utara ni camne pulak?
When the seagulls follow the trawler, it's because they think sardines will be thrown in to the sea.
Reply

Props Report

Rank: 7Rank: 7Rank: 7

Post on 13-10-2010 01:15 PM |All posts
hang tu bodo
Reply

Props Report

Rank: 8Rank: 8

Post on 13-10-2010 02:27 PM |All posts
Hang cangkul...
Reply

Props Report

Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11

Post on 13-10-2010 02:29 PM |All posts
itulah
aku pening jgak baca
tu yg nak dengau pendapat semua
koboi Post at 13-10-2010 11:58


jangan fening2.. baca pendapat srikandi ni..

Kajian Kes:Shahabudeen Jalil dan Hang Tuah
http://mistisfiles.blogspot.com/2010/07/kajian-kesshahabudeen-jalil-dan-hang.html
YM - neo05080201
Reply

Props Report

Rank: 6Rank: 6

Post on 13-10-2010 03:45 PM |All posts
nanti aku bace
corelle,conningware,rejected perfume,spirulina www.facebook.
Reply

Props Report

Rank: 3Rank: 3

Post on 13-10-2010 04:29 PM |All posts
hang hang yang kat belah utara ni camne pulak?
alphawolf Post at 13-10-2010 12:07


ni kena tunggu hangpc masuk dan jawab
Reply

Props Report

Rank: 7Rank: 7Rank: 7

Post on 13-10-2010 05:57 PM |All posts
Dr. Nasoha Saabin
October 2010
Dean of Faculty of Optometry
International University College of Technology Twintech
Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia

hahaha optometry punya pandangan....lgsg takde kesarjanaan dlm tulisan nya...
x lebih dari pandangan dangkal org2 biasa.... x payah di amik pusing pun
Reply

Props Report

Rank: 12Rank: 12Rank: 12

Post on 14-10-2010 11:24 AM |All posts
ni sebenarnya artikel nak question pasal takrif bumiputera & non - bumi

jauh beno dia nak lencong...sampai zaman ahng tuah!
love, thy will be done...
Reply

Props Report

Rank: 8Rank: 8

Post on 14-10-2010 01:25 PM |All posts
ni sebenarnya artikel nak question pasal takrif bumiputera & non - bumi

jauh beno dia nak lencong ...
mala0n Post at 14-10-2010 11:24



tu la pasal....sampai kena korek ke zaman hang tuah la plak....takde keje la tu.....
Reply

Props Report

Rank: 2

Post on 14-10-2010 01:55 PM |All posts
{:2_67:}{:2_67:}
Reply

Props Report

Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11

Post on 14-10-2010 05:48 PM |All posts
ni sebenarnya artikel nak question pasal takrif bumiputera & non - bumi

jauh beno dia nak lencong ...
mala0n Post at 14-10-2010 11:24


betul jugak kata ko
baru den perasan
:&
Reply

Props Report

Defender

A.B. in music, University o ..

Rank: 12Rank: 12Rank: 12

Post on 14-10-2010 06:56 PM |All posts
Post Last Edit by paler kembang at 14-10-2010 18:57

Dah la melayu dah benci dengan melayunya... melayu benci pada ketuanan melayunya,  sultan pun ada yang tak suka pada pihak yang pejuangkan mempertahankan kedudukan kesultanan melayu.. Kutbah jumaat pun doa kat bangsa cina, Hang Tuah pun nak dicinakan!
handsome guy, otai, iphone 5s. Chriit!.. chrit!.. chriiiiit!...
Reply

Props Report

Rank: 5Rank: 5

Post on 14-10-2010 11:39 PM |All posts
mna ada hang tuah...mitos jer tuh...nk perbodohkan rakyat kaedahnya..hang jebat ada la...sbb dia brani sanggah kehendak sultan..tpi bla dh gitu kaedah prangainya..hang jebat tak la plk diestablishkan
Reply

Props Report

Rank: 3Rank: 3

Post on 15-10-2010 12:21 AM |All posts
jgn x tahu


maharaja cina pon suh kuli dia g melaka nak akan air basuhan kaki sultan melaka. nak minum n mandi. supaya sembuh penyakit dia------>>>>sejarah melayu...
Reply

Props Report

Rank: 3Rank: 3

Post on 15-10-2010 08:33 AM |All posts
[code][tak abih2 nak mencinakan hang tuah..
ni mesti geng2 si mamak shahabudin jalil..  /code]

aku setuju...
Reply

Props Report

Rank: 3Rank: 3

Post on 19-10-2010 05:01 PM |All posts
hang tuah adalah org yg sama dengan Tun Saaban, Narai dan Sultan Di Negeri aceh
aku pon dh lupa nama dia time jd raja kt acheh dlu...
Reply

Props Report

Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11

Post on 19-10-2010 11:14 PM |All posts
Reply 1# koboi

Hahahahahahahaaa

The idea of a highly advanced tough noble malay race employing someone from those girlish chinese menfolk as their top warrior is extremly ludicrous.
Reply

Props Report

Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11

Post on 19-10-2010 11:22 PM |All posts
Memang tak masuk akal
laksamana negara melayu datangnya dari kaum cina yang lemah longlai
Reply

Props Report

Rank: 14Rank: 14Rank: 14Rank: 14

Post on 20-10-2010 07:18 AM |All posts
hang tuah dn kawan2 tu org Arab Badawi la..
al - tuah..
al - jebat...
al-kasturi
al-lekiu
al-lekir..
janji rock.....
Reply

Props Report

Rank: 14Rank: 14Rank: 14Rank: 14

Post on 20-10-2010 08:18 AM |All posts
tuah, jebat, kasturi, lekiu, lekir... tu semua kisah mitos je. suma takde kubor ke? tak kawen ke? takde zuriat ke? takyah pening2. tahyul je tu.
Reply

Props Report

12Next
Return Post new threads
You need to login first Login | Register Facebook Login

Important Notice: The views and opinions expressed on the forum or the related pages are of the owner alone, and are not endorsed by CARI, nor is CARI responsible for them. Due to the nature of the Internet forum is in real time, CARI does not, and can not censor any submission, but asks that each user use discretion and respect for other users, and does not contribute any word that is unlawful, harmful, threatening, abusive, harassing, tortious, defamatory, vulgar, obscene, libelous, invasive of another's privacy, hateful, or racially, ethnically or otherwise objectionable. CARI reserve the right to withhold and/or remove any link that might possibly hold an individual, entity or group ridicule, potential embarrassment or potential defamation. CARI also reserves the right to accept, edit and/or remove any link that is deemed inappropriate in any way.
Hosted by

Archiver|Mobile|CARI Malay Forums

GMT+8, 22-8-2014 05:48 PM , Processed in 0.321368 second(s), 35 queries , Gzip On.

Powered by Discuz!

© 2001-2012 Comsenz Inc.

Top