-hasil inspirasi buku yg berjudul The Miracolous Journey of Edward Tulane karangan Kate DiCamillo.
-cite sci-fi ini mengisahkan kehidupan MJ sbg alien dr planet KMT 184.05 yg tlh landing dibumi 400 thn dahulu iaitu sejak zmn Joseon era (1609), suka menyepi tp b'ubah slps suatu tragedi (Yi Hwa). Dgn b'baki masa 3 bln sblm kembali ke planet asal, MJ tlh b'temu dgn SY, seorang hallyu star. Kemunculan SY seolah-olah penjelmaan semula Yi Hwa (reincarnation). Cinta '2 dimensi' antara: superpower dgn superstar (2 identiti b'beza), alien dgn manusia (2 makhluk planet b'beza), 'cool' man dgn sassy girl (2 sifat b'beza).
'THINGS THAT ARE MEANT TO HAPPEN WILL HAPPEN, EARTHLINGS CALL THAT FATE’- MJ
KOMEN DARI SUDUT PENCERITAAN
-Dr segi idea, kisah cinta yg dimanifestasikn dlm bntk 3 gbgn elemen iaitu FATE, DESTINY & SWORE. Pd p'mulaan plot b'kembang dgn baik tp bila part ending, jln cite kurang kritis,ending ‘sarat' dgn adegan romantic dan cara pemergian MJ byk menimbulkan persoalan. Writer cuba buat happy ending, wpun mereka t'pisah antara 2 planet, tetapi mereka masih b'satu (dgn cara teleport shj), kire nk buatkn plot nmpk lebih ‘logik & realistik’, 'alien' dan 'native' mmg xboleh bersatu atas faktor sempadan ekologi. Create lar something SPECIALLL & ending yg unik skt, nama pong cite fantasy. Alangkan CJ7 pun leh pulang balik, xkan MJ takat teleport je kot.
-SUGGESTION END (kesan t/balas darah): kita dh tahu kesan drpd rgsgn air liur, tp nape xtunjuk transaksi darah yg leh jd 'pencetus evolusi' kpd MJ transformation (sblm ni,writer ada ckp yg darah MJ juga tak boleh b'campur dgn human blood. Lagipun darah SY unik).Peranan darah sbg ‘agen pemangkin’ utk satukan cinta SY dan MJ. Part akhir patut selitkn unsur thriller cm pergelutan antara MJ, JK, SY & HK kt cliff br mencabar dan saspen skt.
OVERALL JALAN CERITA
-Cite epic yg menggabungkan mixed genre dpt membentuk plot konkrit & ampuh. Dlmnya ada unsur2 rom-com. Cite ala2 fantasy cm GFB, Prince Rooftop, Arang the Magistrate, My Girlfriend is a Gumiho.
-Sarat dgn info & mesej.Cth, epi4- berkisar ttg rumors yg melanda kehidupan SY, jadi writer cube kaitkn kuliah MJ yg menerangkan lebih lanjut ttg rumors dan epi 13- (5) stages of break up by Kubler–Ross. (anger, denying reality, bargaining, depression and stages of acceptance).
-Subplot yg kemas & teratur. Bahkan byk menimbulkan polimik, persepsi & spekulasi. Ada juga unsur berbaur sindiran yg berkaitrapat dgn reality donia retis. Cth, dlm epi 2, ttg propofol.
-BRAVO Director Jang Tae Yoo & writer Park Ji Eun--Great script, intrigue plot lines. Disebabkn fofulariti, boleh raih award DRAMA OF THE YEAR!!!
FEVERET / MEMORABLE PART
epi 6- tragic scene, Yi Hwa kene panah (MJ xdpt nk protect dek kerana racun)
-ade supernatural power—super sight (xray vision), instinct and super hearing (7x ganda dr manusia), super speed, time freezing (pause n stop dlm mase 1 min.), teleport (dlm 300km), combustion, telekinesis, levitation (fly) dalam epi 18 and superhuman strength (tp suka salah guna kuasa).
-Konservatif, pendiam, bijak berkata-kata and soft spoken--kontra dgn SY sassy girl.
JUN JI HYUN / GIANNA JUN as CHEON SONG YI (SY) [BEST ACTRESS]
-SY ade strong mind, but even if she act’s strong, she’s really frail on the inside- mak SY
-elegan and stylish (hallyu star).
-Talkactive, bubbly and annoy bile dia wat sore manja
PARK HAE JIN as LEE HWI KYEONG (HK) [BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR]
-innocent guy dan menyedihkan coz dpt abg xguna (JK) and the youngest son of the conglomerate (chaebol).
-setia pd SY dan sanggup tunggu wpun direject byk kali oleh SY. Agak lurus bendul tp nmpk bijak skt dlm epi 12, siasat agenda jahat JK.
YOO IN NA as YOO SE MI (SeMi) [BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS]
-actress dan kwn baik SY, dark n gloomy personality, mula2 watak protagonist, tp b'ubah jd antagonis slps insiden kematian Han Yoo Ra.
-cemburu, pendendam dan perampas-sanggop 'tikam' SY.
-Menyedihkan—cinta xb'balas. Menagih cinta HK tp tlh direject.
KOMEN DARI SUDUT LAKONAN
-Watak2 lain cm ‘hanyut tenggelam’ sikit, cth, watak HK naïf & lemah (bab nk selamatkn ex-wife JK pong guna khidmat MJ). Watak semi 'terhad', hanya antagonis yg ‘pasif’. Patutnya karekter semi b'tukar kpd antagonis yg ‘aktif’, cth, cm cube b'subahat dgn JK utk hancurkn cinta MJ dan SY. Watak JK sbg pak dalang kes bunuh Han Yoo Ra, pastu writer ‘matikn’ watak JK dgn hukuman penjara, sedangkn Yi Hwa yg xbersalah tu pong mati tragis, nape watak JK yg penuh noda hitam, kotor, busuk,rakus takat hanya habiskan sisa hidup dia dlm penjara je (patutnya 'musnahkn' watak dia kt cliff).
OVERALL SUDUT LAKONAN
-AMAZING- Good interaction antara para pelakon. VERSATILE- body motion, facial expression/ mimic, posture/gesture, and superb intonation.
-MJ dgn SY mmg lovely couple. Good chemistry and natural acting. CHEMISTRY OVERWHELMING. Boleh menang award ‘COUPLE OF THE YEAR’.
ASPEK TEKNIKAL
LENS FOKUS / CAMERA MOVEMENT
-multi camera setup/ matrix camera--guna teknik ‘time slice’ utk hasilkn effect t'utama scene supernatural power. Cth, dlm epi2, scene MJ buat time freezing utk selamatkn SY dr kemalangan 12 thn lepas (stop pause) @ dipanggil inceptionness dimana semo watak dan lagu dlm scene tersebut ade pause play gitu. Ia adlh teknik yg sama dlm Matrix 3. Teknik plg efektif utk beri feel mendalam dan nmpk lebih real dgn dibantu 60 camera.
-Close-up shot pd scene2 t'tentu,cth, scene nangis, camera close up shot pd mata. Camera long shot utk ‘show’ kan background scene. Cth dlm uma, tyme winter, tyme flying kiss.
-Camera focus pd part2 t’tentu utk kita lebih ‘alert’.Cth, last epi 2, scene MJ sedang rehat sambil dgor music, mase tu camera focus pd ruang uma MJ & focus kt pokok yg ‘segar’, nk menunjukkan perasaan MJ yg gembira.
LIGHTING EDITING
-Biasa lah watak2 antagonis cm JK-lighting dia gelap (darker) dan scene MJ b'sendirian utk tunjukkn emotion sepi. Kekadang imej blkg di ‘blurkan’ utk fokus pd watak. Cth, epi 2 -scene kuliah SY & scene salon. Celestial light—dlm ending, scene meteorites jatuh ke bumi (meteor shower). Apply flash lighting yg sesuai, cth, dlm epi 17, scene Suzy sbg cameo, di mana flash lighting utk berikn kesan glowing scr keseluruhan pd suzy seolah-olah meletakkan dia sbg ‘perfect angle’ mase scene tu, yg bawa watak sbg ‘pencaras’.
INSTRUMENTAL
-GREAT MELODY -music arrangement mengkagumkn, bunyi instrumental lebih harmoni. Bijak ‘muatkn’ instrumental sesuai dgn scene, cth, scene flashback Joseon era, instrumental lebih classic. Plus, music background utk bangkitkn 'feel', cth, you’re my destiny nyanyian paul anka, dlm epi 3, scene MJ pinjam buku kt kedai Bokja. Sound effect utk hasilkn ‘mood’, cth, effect bunyi UFO, dlm epi 5, scene SY tanya MJ, are u an aliens dan scene SY jerit kt Mt. Bukhan (bunyi crow).
CINEMATOGRAPHY
-BEAUTIFUL VIEW- spt Jangsado Sea Park, Mt. Bukhansan, flower garden manhwa café, Songdo－Incheon University, Incheon metropolitan city museum, Petite France, Seoul Museum of Art, and Eland Cruise. Apartment mewah MJ dgn SY nmpk Xclusive. KREATIF- Shin Seung Jun, designer yg deco drama set tu, berbaloi lar pelaburan dorg yg hampir cecah 1 million USD dollar.
-Pengulangan lokasi, cth, cliff tmpt kematian Yi Hwa dlm epi 6 diguna semula pd epi 7, scene SY hampir t'jatuh di cliff dan dlm epi 10, scene MJ kene tembak dgn JK.
FLASHBACK SCENE
-Flashback utk kaitkan scene zmn Joseon era dgn modern era dan kekadang flashback juga berlaku antara scene2 dlm modern era tu sendiri (as a reminder).
-Cth, epi 3-scene kt hospital, masetu turun salji. SY ckp pasal salji kt MJ. Flashback zmn Joseon, MJ teringat kenangan dgn Yi Hwa pasal salji. Dlm epi 17, scene flashback cmne HK leh temui ex-wife JK dgn bantuan MJ. Pengulangan scene, tp lokasi yg b'beza, cth, SeMi nmpk cara MJ selamatkn SY dr t'kena kaca dr atas bgunan (epi7) sama dgn cara MJ selamatkn SY dr accident 12 thn lps (epi 2).
MONOLOG DALAMAN
-epi14- scene MJ dgor SY ckp sorg2 kt balkoni sambil pandang langit, MJ berdiri di sebalik langsir ckp dlm hati:
('when u start to love someone, u also have to fears, because I might not be able to protect someone that I need to protect.’-MJ).
EPILOG
-part akhir epi, seolah-olah rentetan peristiwa bg scene2 yg tergantung. Antara epilog yg plg debes. cth,epi 10--scene SY jumpe doctor psychiatric:
('I always eat chicken and beer when I’m depressed. The girl that got coffee (semi) on that man (MJ) and then wiped it off. I want to break her hand completely.’- SY)
ARTISTICS & SYMBOLICS
-buku the miraculous journey of Edward Tulane dan lukisan hadiah dr Yi Hwa.
-dlm epi 13,scene MJ ‘frust’ menonggeng. MJ pecahkan cawan, jeles dgn HK yg ketika itu sdg berbual dgn SY.
-cliff—kaitan Joseon era dgn modern era.
-ring JK-lambang psycho dan dlm epilog epi 10, SY guna cincin yg sama bila jumpa dgn doctor psychiatrist.
-tumbesaran pokok dlm uma MJ, gambarkn keadaan MJ,cth, epi 12, pokok layu coz MJ sakit manakala pokok di balkoni melambangkn cinta berputik.
HOLOGRAM
-ending epi 17 dan last epi- scene MJ start 'lenyap'
SLOW FEATURING SHOOT
-cth, scene MJ berlari kuar dr kete detektif utk selamat kn SY dr JK.
KOMEN DARI ASPEK TEKNIKAL
- isu nomot uma SY- dlm epi 6, stylish minah order chicken (reject) tp suh anta kt nomot uma 2315 & scene JK b'temu dgn SY guna nomot 2315, padahal uma SY nomot 2301 (epi 1).
- isu bilik investigation room (p'bezaan tombol & kedudukan pintu b'lainan arah)
-isu re-attachment- epi 4 (scene druma MJ ke cabin cruise) dan epi 14 (scene dr sepital ke opis JK), nmpk xkemas coz still nmpk background. Patut camera focus kt kaki cukop.
-isu tarikh-dlm epi 21, scene prosecutor bg hujah kt court, JK 'prime suspect for the death of Han Yoo Ra' on 6 Dec 2013, tp dlm epi 1, ikut diari MJ b'tarikh 18 Dec 2013 (starting cerita), jd ini b'makna kes bunuh Han Yoo Ra adlh slps tarikh t'sebut.
-isu lain yg dibangkitkn (balkoni, posisi bangunan, tgn MJ, handset SY, beza jam epi 17)
OVERALL ASPEK TEKNIKAL
-GOOD JOB- Teknik pengarahan baik, olahan cerita cantik, clear montaj, storyline running smoothly dan time pacing seimbang. Cara handle camera dgn control light mmg nmpk smpurna. Dr segi time frame, composition @ arrangement dia mmg kemas.
-Bijak selitkan elemen t'tentu, cth, parodies song/drama. Cth, epi 5- parody heirs--scene dak kecik wat confession ala2 LMH kt depan kedai comic president Hong dgn background lagu OST heirs-Lee Hong Ki (I’m saying) dan epi 6- parody G-Dragon & Jang Hyung Don (going to try)—scene SY drive kete ’boom boomie’ (version SY).
-CLASSY dari segi attire mmg nmpk mewah sesuai dgn watak mereka yg kaya, antaranya, hermes, lobotin, Gucci, Chanel & Jimmy Choo.
SKOR MUZIK
SENARAI FULL OST
-(4) dr (8) ost plg hit dlm ina music chart
OST 1: Lyn – My Destiny
OST 3: Hyorin - Hello Goodbye
OST 7: Sung Si Kyung- Every moment of you
OST 8: oppa nyanyi- In front of your house
OVERALL SKOR MUZIK
-Sesuai dgn scene dan bantu penonton ‘respon’. Alunan ritma tempo dan bunyi orchestra sgt harmoni boleh bangkitkan aura. Ada lagu dgn melody yg rancak, akustik dan guitar sound. Tone dia soft, x t'lalu harsh sgt.
KEBARANGKALIAN UTK TONTONAN SEMULA
-ulang tayang scene oppa je. gigih tgk cite ni siap streaming bagai, wpun sepatah pong xpaham
-buktinya moyan smpai fasa 5...UNBELIEVABLE tp bg aku NOORRMAAAALLLL
TOTAL : ( 8 + 9 + 9 + 5 + 4 = 8.75)
***tgk uma HK cm uma jisung secret love.......bapak dia pong sejenis (sama perangai)
***jalan cite pong ade p'samaan....mula2 benci, pastu suka, sebok dgn buku, dan trip kt villa
***idea ni xleh aplikasi kalo ade season 2
miahe sbb lambat......@dauswq@cess@ayushuhada04 @melati_kesuma dan semo yg sudi bace Last edited by inaniloquent on 6-8-2014 08:53 PM
cess posted on 14-3-2014 09:38 AM
mmg kalo ina xleh caya sgt ayu @inaniloquent ...cess pnh tgk dia review cite secret love...be ...
tu le pasal...mcm2 ler alasan dia...
nk buat option 2 ler....
ayu lak mati2 percaya dia tk leh buat option 1...
ermm....senang2 jer ayu tertipu tau.....
kecik gak hati ni....
Post time 13-3-2014 02:42 PM
Author
Post time 13-3-2014 02:59 PM
Last edited by inaniloquent on 6-8-2014 08:53 PM 
padann laa susah nk paste..lengkap + padat + jitu lagik 
...cess pnh tgk dia review cite secret love...bersungguh cess baca
![[Edisi tahniah] Selamat Pengantin baru Afifah Nasir!](https://uf.cari.com.my/forumx/mforum/block/c9/c97d679eb37ef49a51786bd2e594be95.jpg)
