|
View: 3699|Reply: 13
|
bawang merah dan bawang putih
[Copy link]
|
|
|
hari ini saya tengok cerama agama isu pasal muhammad di tv3 pukul 7mlm
menurut , muhammad melarang makan bawang putih dan bawang merah sebab bau nya ...jadi ia tidak elok bila berdoa pada allah kerana bau bawang putih...
konsep ini sama macam hindus di mana hindus tidak memakan bawang merah dan bawang putih..agama yg amalkan sayuran.
kadang2 saya melihat islam ini ada campur aduk dari hindusim dan yahudi...
Hadith no. 870Hadis Ibnu Umar r.a: Sesungguhnya Rasulullah s.a.w pernah bersabda ketika dalam peperangan Khaibar: Sesiapa yang memakan dari pohon ini iaitu bawang putih maka janganlah dia memasuki masjid.
Hadis Anas r.a:
Anas pernah ditanya mengenai bawang putih. Anas menjawab: Sesungguhnya Rasulullah s.a.w pernah bersabda: Sesiapa yang memakan pohon ini maka janganlah dia mendekati kami dan jangan sembahyang bersama kami.
Anas's Hadith, may Allah be pleased with him.
Anas was asked about the garlic; he stated that the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) had said: He who eats of this plant (garlic) should neither approach us nor pray along with us. Hadith number in Sahih Muslim [Arabic only]: 872
Nombor hadith di dalam Sahih Muslim : 872
In Hindusim:
Why is it Forbidden to Eat Onions and Garlic?
In Gadhada Part 1, Chapter 78 of the Vachanamrut, Lord Swaminarayan states that God becomes truly pleased those who flawlessly abide by the five vows (panch vartman).
One of these five vows is to refrain from eating anything that contains, or has been in contact with meat. Jeevanpran Shree Abji Bapashree explains in the Rahasyarth Pradeepka Teeka of this Vachanamrut, that one can only claim to have abided by this vow flawlessly, if they also refrain from consuming unwashed grain, unfiltered water, garlic, onion, asafoetida (hingh), etc. In likening onion and garlic to meat, Jeevanpran Bapashree has highlighted the importance of abstaining from eating these items.
The three qualities of Maya (satva, rajas, and tamas) exist in varying levels within one's mind. Satva are the qualities comprising of tranquillity, restraint, purity and peace of mind. Rajas are the passion and pleasure seeking attributes of Maya. Tamas are the evil qualities that lead one to become angry, resentful, arrogant and destructive. In order to concentrate one's mind on the Lord, the qualities of rajas and tamas must be suppressed, allowing the satvik qualities to prevail. Various foods and drink can influence the state of one's mind and can therefore manipulate the levels of satva, rajas and tamas. For example, alcohol lowers inhibitions and invokes rajsik qualities such as lust. In the same manner, onions, garlic, asafoetida, etc, raise tamsik qualities such as anger. Disciples of the Lord must avoid any food or drink that are considered rajsik or tamsik because these cause a hindrance in their worship of God. Whilst rajsik or tamsik qualities are prevalent, one's mind will not remain calm. Therefore, whilst in these states, one cannot meditate on God. When the quality of satva prevails, meditation and faithful worship can be performed. Therefore, a disciple of God must ensure that their mind continually suppresses all rajsik and tamsik natures and establishes the state of satva. One must ensure that all of one's senses, including taste, are controlled and kept pure - in order for the mind to be kept pure. Purity of mind, deeds and speech, are the manners through which one can please the Lord. From a social perspective, the consumption of strong tasting and highly aromatic foods such as onions and garlic can lead to bodily odours, which are both unsociable and disrespectful to others. Eating onions for example will inevitably lead to bad breath. The consumption of garlic, even in minute quantities, can lead to several days of an unsavoury odour being emitted from the pores of the skin. Being in such a malodorous state in the presence of the Lord or His sants, is a sign of disrespect and disregard for them. If one wishes to remain close to the Lord forever, they must avoid anything that could cause offence to God and His sants. Onions and garlic fall into the category of tamsik and offensive foods and are therefore forbidden.
Last edited by Truth.8 on 9-3-2014 08:09 PM
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
tak ada komen2 ke? madam sepi any comment? |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Tak semua Hadis itu betul, hadis ada jugak yg lemah, atau daif yg salah, atau yang bertentangan dengan Quran. Hadis diriwayatkan manusia, manusia takde sempurna boleh buat kesalahan.
Yang betul hanya Al-Qur'an kerana ianya datang langsung dari Tuhan. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Truth.8 posted on 10-3-2014 10:50 AM 
tak ada komen2 ke? madam sepi any comment?
Tak ada salah makan bawang putih dan merah(halal), yang dimaksudkan makan banyak sehingga mulut jadi busuk dan badan jadi busuk. Mengganggu orang lain. Kalau tak percaya kau makanlah 10 ulas bawang putih tu, peluh dan badan kau jadi busuk, awek kau pun lari...
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Setuju zamkumis, kalau makan satu bakul memang salah lah tu  |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Carilah truth kesalahan Islam tu, kau takkan jumpa sampai bila-bila. Islam tu sempurna, yang bermasalah orang islam yang tak amal agama. Memburukkan imej islam |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
zamkumis posted on 10-4-2014 01:14 PM
Tak ada salah makan bawang putih dan merah(halal), yang dimaksudkan makan banyak sehingga mulut ja ...
aku rasa ikut macam masakan bawang putih dan bawang merah....
saya makan atau di masak sehingga bawang putih dan merah di masak dengan kuah curry sehingga ia menjadi lembut...jadi ia tidak ada bau kuat...
kalau makan goreng2 aja, pasti ada bau kuat dlm mulut...
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
zamkumis posted on 10-4-2014 02:49 PM
Kalau nak sperm pekat makan bawang putih, kalau nak banyak sperm bawang merah
cuba truth jan ...
bukan bawang merah aja tapi boleh makan biji fenuside yg selalu orang india masak dgn kuah curry. ia mempunyai bahan testoren ....cuba kamu google fenugreek tapi jgn banyak sangat...selalu saya masak dgn kuah curry ikan , dal campuran hebal lain termasuk bawang putih dan merah sehingga ia lembut dan masak cukup ...tak ada bau .. cubalah
Last edited by Truth.8 on 10-4-2014 03:37 PM
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Garlic is rajasik (stimulative, increase your temporal passion).
Onion is tamasik (dark, increasing your ignorance)...
If you practice Bhakti discipline and if you're a Yogi, then you've to avoid both of these in your food.
Take more fresh fruits, dairy products, legumes, grains, herbs, vegetables and so on according to your prescribed traditions. You can check your prescription for food through your body and mind pathogenic agents..
You use rajasik materials only in certain conditions and in certain prescribed amount... If you eat garlic raw, you're potential to be subjected to the harmful bacteria (botulism)...
As a Vaishnava Hindu, we don't take garlic either especially we have to offer the food to the God and Guru (for blessings) before we eat them...
This is our simple ayurveda science...
What you see as close in traditions perhaps could be seen through the lens of Perennial philosophy. You cannot simply say a certain religion borrows this from here and there. It is against the proper epistemological analysis on the nature of knowledge and how it relates to connected notions such as truth, belief and justification. Judaism is only a tradition in Israelites' religion. There are also Samaritanism, Karaite Judaism, Notzrim Messianic Jewish (Christian Jewish) and so on. They do not share the same minor sages or historical development. Others are the Sabians such as those in Harran and Mandean Gnosticism... These are among the religions of the Middle Easterners other than Islam (many kinds of Islam) which spreads around the globe together with Christianity with its different offshoots of sects...
Last edited by vikramavardhana on 20-5-2014 06:32 PM
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
melarang kat sini bukan disebabkan bawang tersebut tapi disebabkan bau yg terhasil selepas makan bawang. bila mulut bau busuk..kau solat jemaah tepi orang lain..kembang kempis orang sebelah kau menahan bau. ini mengganggu orang nak beribadat.
bila mulut bau busuk juga...bila kau bercakap-cakap dengan kawan nanti kalau kawan kau buat muka "tak selesa" kau juga yang terasa hati. kalau kawan kau sound "mulut kau busuk" kau juga terasa hati nanti. mungkin kau tak terasa..tapi ada certain orang kat dunia ni jenis hati nipis senang terasa
sebab tu awal-awal diberitahu "kalau makan bawang jangan dekati dengan orang"
kat tanah arab..masakan bawang dia tak sama dengan masakan bawang malaysia. ada yang makan mentah ada yg masak sikit2 je. kita sini masak bawang tak bau sangat
tapi kat malaysia ada makanan lain yang bau...contohnya durian, petai, bla-bla tambah sendiri. aku pernah solat tepi pak cik yang bila pakcik tu sendawa bau durian...1 rakaat sendawa 2,3 kali. pergh! rasa nak pukul je pak cik tu. hancur solat aku tak khusyuk bau durian dari perut dia. sabar je la time tu. tapi dia minta maaf lepas solat. macam tau2 je aku sedang marah kat dia
ini adalah ADAB dalam islam. detailnya islam dalam memberikan adab sehingga soal makanan tu disentuh. tapi yelah..tapi tak semua ikut. belajar macam2 dalam sekolah memandu tapi bila drive tak ikut juga last2 sendiri accident |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
vikramavardhana posted on 20-5-2014 06:13 PM
Garlic is rajasik (stimulative, increase your temporal passion).
Onion is tamasik (dark, increasing ...
bagus explaination. thanks bro
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
anwarnuwa posted on 20-5-2014 11:32 PM
bagus explaination. thanks bro
Welcome
Regards,
Vikram
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
vikramavardhana posted on 21-5-2014 02:13 AM
Garlic is rajasik (stimulative, increase your temporal passion).
Onion is tamasik (dark, increasing ...
it good to take little garlic because it can lower cholestrol and bring out gas in our stomach....
onion also good but all in moderate
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
Post time 9-3-2014 07:16 PM
变色卡
Author
