Dan Brown - new book: The Lost Symbol

sherrina

limau,
kira masih x rugi le kalau kita gi tgk kat cinema? ke kurang berbaloi dan better tunggu dvd ah pek?

limau_nipis

Originally posted by sherrina at 18/5/06 08:38 PM
limau,
kira masih x rugi le kalau kita gi tgk kat cinema? ke kurang berbaloi dan better tunggu dvd ah pek?

sherrina, pendapat orang berbeza-beza.. for the people who love the book, they will be disappointed
kalau tak pernah baca, they sure like the movie..

tapi for me, cerita dia ok gak because of the visual.. but chemistry between sophie and langdon is not there, very stiff performance.. mcm tak boleh connect with both characters at all.. and tom hanks' age did catch up with him, mmg nampak tua sangat dan macam letih je sepanjang cerita tu.. but for the feast of an eye, boleh la tgk france and london

boleh nak tgk, tapi lepas tgk tu, tak rasa nak tgk lagi sekali.. like, once is enough

Robab

aaaaaaaa
tidak~!!
so, agaknye watak robert langdon boleh direplace ngn george clooney?
what a disappoinment
why should he change the ending???

limau_nipis

Originally posted by Robab at 19/5/06 09:22 AM
aaaaaaaa
tidak~!!
so, agaknye watak robert langdon boleh direplace ngn george clooney?
what a disappoinment
why should he change the ending???

robab, it is very noticable.. the ending..
tapi yang part langdon tahu mary magdelene bersemadi kat louvre tu still ada..

but where they found rosalynn chapel.. hah, itu yang lain sangat dengan apa yang ada dalam buku.. mmg lain sgt sgt sgt

willy_wonka

Originally posted by limau_nipis at 18-5-2006 10:16 AM
nak tulis review ke tak ni? kang mcm spoil cerita... sian lak sherrina and the geng nak gi tgk cerita tu

anyhow, nak pesan.. cerita tu not up to the expectation - maybe expectation myself too hi ...

aku tak tgk lagi citer ni sbb buku pun xhabis baca..
nk habiskan baca buku dulu..
mmg tak letak high expectation pun utk dis movie sbb cam kes harry potter la..for me lg best yg dlm buku..imposibble nk msukan sume scene dlm buku into movie kan..
rasa paul bettany mmg sesuai bw watak silas..muka dia mmg nmpk ganas..
tom hanks nape tgk cam xbmaya jer??
tapi cam xbest la kalu dlm movie xinclude psl PHI..sbb tu antara bnda menarik to me..pada org yg xbaca buku mesti dorang xtahu..

limau_nipis

Originally posted by willy_wonka at 19/5/06 12:11 PM



aku tak tgk lagi citer ni sbb buku pun xhabis baca..
nk habiskan baca buku dulu..
mmg tak letak high expectation pun utk dis movie sbb cam kes harry potter la..for me lg best yg dlm buku..i ...

but willy, HP bukunya makin mendatar.. tapi filemnya makin bagus

sherrina

baca kat The Star masa opening kat Cannes, journalist snickers at the movie. I wonder why.

willy_wonka

Originally posted by limau_nipis at 19-5-2006 12:34 PM


but willy, HP bukunya makin mendatar.. tapi filemnya makin bagus

yup :setuju:..aku perasan start buku no 5 ler bila rowling dah matikan watak2 best..even aku sendiri xbaca buku 5 n 6..

megangsta86

lurvesss dis book...btw tom hanks is so handsome in the movie..:love:

megangsta86

semlm aku nk g tgk cite nie...tp ticket dh sold out smpi ke mlm.i'm hoping dis movie will be as good as the novel..:pray:

nevekiara

I recommend all Dan Brown books, including Da Vinci Code, best!

sherrina

baru tgk tadi kol 5. bolehlah, nak kata best giler tu tak. but nak kata tertido pun tak. bleh kasik 3/5 le utk filem ni. Tom Hanks rasanya x sesuai le sbb nampak tua dan si Sophie tu nampak cam tak match ngan citer ni. Antara scene yg paling disukai ialah semasa Robert beri ceramah simbologi dan memaparkan slide2 simbol. menarik dan tak terpikir pun sebelum ini.

KRUfan

Nak try baca buku ni..

limau_nipis

as I said earlier.. pendapat org berbeza beza.. tapi masa langdon terangkan pasal simbol tu... very nice

hamizao

Baru tengok pukul 2.30 petang tadi Ingatkan hujung minggu  dan minggu depan mesti ramai orang ......sekolah cuti. Itupu kalau2 students minat cerita2 gini.

Hami rasa OK juga.....hanya watak Robert kurang power compared to Teabing, Silas dan yang lain2.  Dialogue Teabing baik macam English gentlemanlah. Tapi ada satu tempat ada banyak explanation...rasa2 Hami nak tertidor sekejap .....Overall OK, entertaining. Ending dia pun baik ...seperti yang di faham oleh Hami masa baca buku dia.

Ini pendapat Hamilah..................

sherrina

limau,
tu lah. kalaulah dapat tgk full presentation mcm tu kat Malaysia, menarik kan?

p/s: penangan Da Vinci Code. Pagi tadi mengajar kat kindy suh student bukak template kat komputer. template tu nama symbol. blaja pasal simbol2 cuaca. bila nak save, tersuruh dorang save as symbology. abis software reject sebab pjg sgt...hahaha...tu lah kalut dengan Da Vinci Code nye pasal...:p

ni memang citer tak masuk akal... da tengok filem. x sampai 5 minit da nampak bontot org tua tu...lucah betul! kwakwakwa!

periwinkle..

hmm.. masih belum tengok cerita ni... anyway, tadi terdengar dalam radio akan dibuat pulak prequel cerita ni sebab sambutan yang hangat.. adaptation cerita angel & demon pulak.. angel & demon ni, buku dia tak berapa fast pace macam DVC, so mungkin bila jadi movie lebih menarik... just have to wait and see..

yaneng

dah tengok the movie and overall it was entertaining, quite a good screenplay if we are to compare to the other book adaptation films....(ie memoirs of a geisha...what a dissappointment)

i felt that amelie was a good actress in this film, have watched nearly all her cinematography and i think she was excellent, esp paired with a "hollywood superstar" her character was noticeable....its true that tom hanks looked a bit tired but who else could be robert langdon...not george clooney....pls...he's charming but we need intelligence in this film....(no offense...)

I was pleasantly surprised that Ron Howard has managed to incorporate at least 85% of the book in this film, he used the characters' narrative to explain in image of the events/occurance leading to the trail....and it was not overwhelming, just felt right and made the readers/non-readers to understand the film/story even better.....

overall a good film to go to the cinema to and you will not feel the 2 1/2 hours......

amadeus

Originally posted by Ameenya at 15-5-2006 10:18 AM
i don't like the ending.. since this book is about code, the ending patutnya buat la teka teki sikit..
conclusion, this book sucks.

me too..don't like the ending...mula2..memang menarik...make me keep on reading..tapi bila ending..i was like.