KS-1A ATM choice?

gancity

KS-1A ATM choice?









source from: http://jczs.news.sina.com.cn/bbs/p/2006/1031/14599118.html

KS-1A? BUK-M1-2? ASTER 15/30? :hmm: 3 also my choice but i thk ATM jst hv enough $ for 1...i thk ASTER 15/30 more likely will be ATM choice..... wat u guess thk?

[ Last edited by  gancity at 3-11-2006 05:40 PM ]

BeachBoys

aku lebih suka buk mi-2....

supergripen

only 2 missiles per launcher huh??? at least the Buk M1 has twice that number.

i'd prefer a setup where u have vertical launched missiles like the Aster series although those might prove to be just out of reach given our shamelessly tiny budget.

so i guess the Buk M1 will be my practical/real world choice la..

edmundo

Russian Buk-M1...
Shh....its calling for us..."Book-Me...Book-Me..."
Apa lagi...ok ke?..:ting:

BeachBoys

kalu jadik beli kene beli untuk lebig drpd 4 rejimen pertahanan udara...(kuantan, pontian, lumut, penang, miri)

johngage

I suspect that Aster will be too expensive. One battery of BUK-M1-2 is around $15-20 million. One battery of SAMP-T is around $47 million. I only hope its not the KS-1A. I heard that it has a lot of probs.

hijazzains

KS-1A is not even used by the PRC themselves!!!!!

I say stick to BUK-M1 :pray:

gancity

the 1st choice for me also Buk-m1..aster is 2nd...but for KS-1A is the package is very interestingfor us...TOT FN-6 to us

[ Last edited by  gancity at 4-11-2006 11:20 AM ]

paleface0711

Originally posted by BeachBoys at 3-11-2006 06:16 PM
kalu jadik beli kene beli untuk lebig drpd 4 rejimen pertahanan udara...(kuantan, pontian, lumut, penang, miri)

Jernas pun kita beli 3 batteries (for total of 9 launchers). Gonna be tough for us to buy enough BuK-M1 for 4 rejimens.

gancity

Jernas is short range...i thk the cost is cheaper then middle range SAM...by the way our 9MP military spend seem dun hv enough budget for us buy more..

windof

My 2 cent thought say KS-1 will be chosen although I hope it will not, as u guys prefer the most Buk M1 also my 1st choice.

johngage

<<Jernas pun kita beli 3 batteries (for total of 9 launchers). Gonna be tough for us to buy enough BuK-M1 for 4 rejimens>>

Saya ingat 1 bateri= 6 launcher. Atau dalam ATM, 1 bateri=3 launcher? Tolong bagii penjelasan, berapa launcher dalam satu bateri ATM?

gancity

For wat I know about Jernas is 3 launcher, 1 Blindfire tracking radar and 1 Dagger surveillance radar consider 1 standard squad/battalion(i no sure how to determine it)  & ATM jst brought 2 battalion onli...

1 batt = 6 launcher? takkan kot..configuration berbeza...kalau satu launcher ada 4 missile...takkan 6 launcher letak satu tempat?...untuk meriam bole pakai la configuration tu...1 batt = 6 pucuk meriam

johngage

<<1 batt = 6 launcher? takkan kot..configuration berbeza...kalau satu launcher ada 4 missile...takkan 6 launcher letak satu tempat?...untuk meriam bole pakai la configuration tu...1 batt = 6 pucuk meriam>>

Dalam artikel in dalam Wikipedia tentang BUK (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SA-11_Gadfly), penulis ini kata:

"Each battery typically consists of a command vehicle, surveillance radar vehicle, SIX TELARs and SIX reload/launch vehicles"

TELAR itu adalah: Transporter Erector Launcher. Tiap Tiap TELAR BUK ada 4 missile:



Kerana ini saya ingat 1 bateri= 6 launcher.

[ Last edited by  johngage at 4-11-2006 10:48 PM ]

BeachBoys

Originally posted by paleface0711 at 4-11-2006 11:05 AM


Jernas pun kita beli 3 batteries (for total of 9 launchers). Gonna be tough for us to buy enough BuK-M1 for 4 rejimens.

buleh consider kot untuk 4 rejimen,sama mcm battery je benanya..tapi kompleks skit pasal dier xserupe ngan jernas tu..dia ada kelengkapan yang lebih darpda jernas jadi xkan nak guna istilah battery mesti pakai rejimen  lakot baru padan.satu lagi dier nye harga murah kalu nak compare ngan diernye kelengkapan..

BeachBoys

kalu leh dapat S-300 lagi bagus..hehe..long distance punye air defense...

areguard

Sistem pertahanan negara bakal meliputi penggunaan pelbagai aset dari negaa pengeluar berbeza. ADa dari UK [Rapier dan Jernas], China [KS-1A] lepas tu cadang nak pakai Vera E dari Ukraine. Boleh ke semuanya tu integrate dengan sistem MADGE sedia ada?

reinloch

The value of ground-based AD is to force the enemy to conduct SEAD. For this purpose, the cheaper Chinese solution is sufficient. We should not be looking for a show-stopping system. This is the RMAF's job, which they are ill-equipped to do right now.

reinloch

Moreover, we should for once discard our illogical norm of buying in tiny batches. The cheaper Chinese system helps somewhat.