|
|
|
syafinaz ada nyanyi satu lagu patriotik kat RTM...selalu gak kuar kat tv...power habis bg aku...lupa lak tajuk lagu tu...nyanyi ala2 soprano...kalau IL boleh komen bagus gak... |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by itikganas at 7-3-2006 11:55 PM
K irving... so what's JAC's highest note? yang AJL20 encore tu???
yg AJL20 encore tu dia nyanyi masa menang kan? aku tak d/load. bgla aku. then i'll look into it. but apa yg aku dah dgr drpd jac setakat nie, x kirala live performance atau studio recordings, her highest notes are always a C6 in falsetto. her highest chest voice would be an F5/G5 so far. that would make her A5 and B5 falsetto jugak. yg paling jelas C6 jac masa dia perform Gemilang utk M'sian Idol Finale showdown. aku ada video dia tapi xde mp3. sesapa bleh upload x mp3 tu?
here's one example of Jac hitting a C6 (in falsetto), her highest note so far. Ni masa perform gemilang utk AJL20(bukan encore tu):
Jaclyn Victor - C6 - Gemilang
however C6 nie tak secantik C6 dia masa M'sian Idol finale tu. yg masa tu mmg perfect gila dan meremang aku dgr part tu. very high walaupun belum masuk whistle register lagi.personally aku rasa dgn sedikit training mcm idayu, jac bleh mencapai whistle register.
ni plak is an A5 (in falsetto) from Jac. sama performance dgn clip tadi:
Jaclyn Victor - A5 - Gemilang
maybe some ppl would say takde perbezaan pun yg C6 dgn A5 tu tapi actually yg C6 tu lebih "lighter/ringan" kalo dgr betul2 berbanding the A5 dan the C6 tu cam ada "unsur" whistling.
personally, aku rasa Jac's vocal range is abt 2.5 octaves.
i'm thinking (and based on my personal observation):
Voice Type: Lyric Soprano (sbb her natural Timbre and Weight of her voice is very Light and Feminine)
Highest Note: C6 (in Falsetto) - Various Gemilang performances and other studio recordings in her album, F5/G5 (in Chest Voice) - Various Gemilang performances, not sure abt her songs in the album sbb aku cuma ada tape-nya.
Lowest Note: Around a D3/E3.
Vocal Range: 2.5 octaves approximately.
Longest Note: 13 seconds for Gemilang studio version, 8 seconds for Gemilang live performance - both occurred during the climax of Gemilang bila lagu tu nak habis.
and aku nak komen skit psl Jac's voice. aku rasa it's starting to deteriorate. maybe perasaan aku je kot.hehe.
ps-post lah lagi note2 tinggi jac kalo sesapa ada or note2 rendah dia.. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by IrvingLorenzo at 9-3-2006 05:39 PM
yg AJL20 encore tu dia nyanyi masa menang kan? aku tak d/load. bgla aku. then i'll look into it. but apa yg aku dah dgr drpd jac setakat nie, x kirala live performance atau studio recordings, h ...
nak dgr tak suara dia masa dia hit low notes dlm bring out the best in me?...nak tau gak what note..but i think dlm third octave la..
[ Last edited by idolfan at 9-3-2006 05:50 PM ] |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by IrvingLorenzo at 9-3-2006 05:39 PM
yg AJL20 encore tu dia nyanyi masa menang kan? aku tak d/load. bgla aku. then i'll look into it. but apa yg aku dah dgr drpd jac setakat nie, x kirala live performance atau studio recordings, h ...
i personally think she can go lower than D3..erm..nak dgr low notes dia plak for cinta duet with misha?
Jac - Cinta |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by burung_pungguk at 9-3-2006 05:14 PM
syafinaz ada nyanyi satu lagu patriotik kat RTM...selalu gak kuar kat tv...power habis bg aku...lupa lak tajuk lagu tu...nyanyi ala2 soprano...kalau IL boleh komen bagus gak...
my fren once said during one of national choir practices, syafinaz hit the last note on the piano.. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by calmille at 8-3-2006 02:59 AM
aku rasa website yg ko masuk tu ialah ni: www.greatestvoices.blogdrive.com
meh aku quote apa yg ada dlm tu:
QUOTE:
Siti Nurhaliza - Vocal profile
* Voice type: Lyric Contralto (with Mezzo and Soprano abilities)
* Highest note: C6 (Oda Bumi Anbiya), F#5 (Lembaran Cinta Pudar)
* Lowest note: B2 ("Dialah Di Hati" LIVE @ Royal Albert Hall), A2 (Kurniaan Dalam Samaran)
* Vocal range: 3.2 octaves (A2-C6)
* Longest Note : 16 seconds (Siti sang Kudaku Lari)
yg website greatest voices tu bukannya bleh percaya sgt.hehe. i mean bukannya aku nak bias or belagak or anything tapi website tu sendiri ckp dia ambik sumber2 dia drpd wikipedia dan wikipedia says that stuff like that hasn't been verified from reliable sources. cuba pegi wikipedia dan check bhgn whistle register singers pastu tgk some of the singers haven't been confirmed tapi wikipedia kan boleh ditambah info sesuka hati by anyone or dipotong. tu yg wikipedia xleh dipercayai 100 peratus. aku sendiri ada baca org tanya psl reliability whistle register singers dan vocal range diorg (especially penyanyi barat) kt wikipedia dlm forum muse's music forum and the moderator kt sana ckp jgn percaya 100 percent sbb some of them are wrong and EXAGGERATED. pastu kan website greatest voices tu sebenarnya tak tau yg wikipedia main ambik je drpd ada website sorang budak pompuan nie (website tu dah takde) bertajuk Notes and Octaves. moderator kt Muse kata some parts of the vocal ranges are exaggerated/dilebihkan contohnya dulu rachelle ferrell's highest note ditulis sbg E7 dlm lagu It Only Took A Minute tapi sbnarnya D7 (tapi dah dibetulkan kt wikipedia dan greatest voices tu), one note lebih rendah drpd E7 lepas didgr berkali2 dan dibandingkan dgn other whistle notes. pastu nak confirmkan lagi, ada sorang forummer kt situ guna Grand Piano 88 keys (dia terer guna piano) utk pastikan note2 yg betul. yg budak pompuan kt website Notes and Octaves tu guna Musebook's Tuner utk kira high/low notes. Musebook's Tuner ni satu alat pengukur elektronik tak silap aku utk ukur notes and octaves. tapi it's not really reliable sbb Note yg dipaparkan kt Musebook tu bleh "throw-off" atau diganggu dan input note salah sbb of the surrounding environment/ external interferences/other noises bleh campur. contohnya, kita ukur satu lagu, let's say lagu Mariah - Emotions Live. katakanla the highest note she reaches is an E7 tapi disebabkan gangguan dari sekeliling masa dia capai that E7 - to be specific, gangguan drpd the drummer hitting the cymbals, the guitarist playing the guitar, the crowd screaming, mungkin Musebook akan "pick up" several notes higher from the E7, like maybe a C8. even angin bleh "throw-off" a note kalo it's in the clip. same kalo kite dgr clip2 lagu, contohnya the F5 from Celine Dion in All By Myself. bhgn tu ada drum dan violin kan? those external noises can throw-off the notes a bit higher sbb Musebook akan ambil kira the notes emanating/coming from the Violin and Drum (and also the voice of Celine). and kalo nak tau, Violin's create very high notes in the seventh octave. so ahli2 muzik kt forum tu ckp kt aku Musebook's Tuner nie x reliable sgt sbb tak tepat. kalo nak paling tepat, use the piano, esp. a grand piano 88 keys. atau a violin or piccolo or apa2 alat muzik yg bleh correspond dgn note yg ko nak tau. mcm aku, aku just tanya je terus kt forum tu. and also dgr byk clip2 suara, lagu,etc utk biasakan diri. the moderator there says biasakan diri mendgr notes by comparing and listening always.
so in the end, greatest voices tu tak bleh dipercayai sgt sbb dia main ambik je info2 tu drpd wikipedia which stole from website notes and octaves yg dah tak wujud lagi and notes and octaves isn't that reliable sbb bergantung kpd Musebook tuner dan bukan a piano. plus info2, wikipedia tu mcm tak tepat plak. contohnya, mana ada Rachelle Ferrell capai F7 and kalo ada pun lagu apa? lagu With Open Arms dia bukannya F7 tapi C#7 actually.pastu tukar2 lak info kadang2 tu aku tgk.x stick to their info.
[ Last edited by IrvingLorenzo at 9-3-2006 06:37 PM ] |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by idolfan at 9-3-2006 05:59 PM
i personally think she can go lower than D3..erm..nak dgr low notes dia plak for cinta duet with misha?
Jac - Cinta
Brader....itu masih lagi dalam octave ke-3 (sekitar note e3 atau f3), cuma dia rendahkan lagi pitching dier. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
best pulak thread ni... 
bdoy n irving... debat ar lagi..
nasib baik flying bee tak masuk campur gak...  ... |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by wgd4082 at 9-3-2006 06:15 PM
Brader....itu masih lagi dalam octave ke-3 (sekitar note e3 atau f3), cuma dia rendahkan lagi pitching dier.
really?..hmm..maybe because i compare kan with voice..hoho... |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by wgd4082 at 9-3-2006 06:15 PM
Brader....itu masih lagi dalam octave ke-3 (sekitar note e3 atau f3), cuma dia rendahkan lagi pitching dier.
agrre...i think its somewhere there...coz the first note i think g#3 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by calmille at 8-3-2006 03:03 AM
irving, mcm mana korg bleh ukur note2 tu, guna software ke?
ko baca posting aku yg sblm nie yg panjang tu psl komen aku psl website greatest voices. aku just tanya org. paling reliable guna grand piano yg ada 88 keys up until a C8. paling senang tapi x reliable guna Musebook's Tuner. baca the rest dlm post aku tu. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by sayangidaku at 8-3-2006 01:53 PM
aah, mmg takde. itule soh irving or sesapa yg arif tolong watkan utk penyanyi lain.
sabar ye...aku bukan terer bab2 nie so kena tanya real experts yg guna piano and take vocal classes utk memastikan their profile. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by IrvingLorenzo at 9-3-2006 06:26 PM
ko baca posting aku yg sblm nie yg panjang tu psl komen aku psl website greatest voices. aku just tanya org. paling reliable guna grand piano yg ada 88 keys up until a C8. paling senang tapi x ...
cool..im downloading the software now...but trial punyala |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by aphrodisiac at 8-3-2006 06:56 PM
website tu reliable ke...tu cuma blog je kan..dulu aku penah masuk gak...selalu nampak fans siti ngan regine bergaduh...hehe..filipino sibok promote regine asia's songbird la, etc...fans ct pon sam ...
tula..x bleh dipercayai sgt.cuba baca explanation aku yg panjang kt atas tu. the best way is to use the piano. and unfortunately aku xde piano. so kena tunggu org confirmkan... |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by wgd4082 at 9-3-2006 06:15 PM
Brader....itu masih lagi dalam octave ke-3 (sekitar note e3 atau f3), cuma dia rendahkan lagi pitching dier.
i think da dpt..she hit d3 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by burung_pungguk at 9-3-2006 05:14 PM
syafinaz ada nyanyi satu lagu patriotik kat RTM...selalu gak kuar kat tv...power habis bg aku...lupa lak tajuk lagu tu...nyanyi ala2 soprano...kalau IL boleh komen bagus gak...
sorryla masalahnya aku tak pernah dgr lagu2 atau performance syafinaz kecuali lagu ingin bersamamu tu. bgla mp3 lagu patriotik tu and maybe i can look into it.atau sesapa yg ada lagu tu? |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by idolfan at 9-3-2006 05:49 PM
nak dgr tak suara dia masa dia hit low notes dlm bring out the best in me?...nak tau gak what note..but i think dlm third octave la..
bleh gak...bagila..ni versi studio rite?xde CD dia la so mls nak dgr tape dah sbb tape x clear. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by IrvingLorenzo at 9-3-2006 06:45 PM
bleh gak...bagila..ni versi studio rite?xde CD dia la so mls nak dgr tape dah sbb tape x clear.
tapi i rasa dlm third octave..so tak payah la..hehehe |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by idolfan at 9-3-2006 06:05 PM
my fren once said during one of national choir practices, syafinaz hit the last note on the piano..
seriously?!! : wow that's like a C8. extremely high!mesti dah nipis sgt her whistle note. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
aku x rasa la syafinaz tu blh C8 whisle dier. Aku penah dengo whisle dier skali, tp x la tinggi mcm C8. bunyi burung pon x der
Dan Jac memang sore x rendah langsung. i think, it's E3, tp biase la, kekadang kite dengo mcm rendah, tp hakikatnya x cukup rendah.
and irving, aku dah dengo compare dgn clip2 tu. i'm still not sure. tp rasenya mcm F5 keatas. Bunyi sore barbra memang sebijik mcm celine dlm all by myself. tp, rasenya sore Barbra mcm lbh tinggi skit. Org memang jarang bercakap pasal kehebatan sore Barbra ni. Iyerla, bg mereka aset sebenar barbra bkn die punye kekuatan vokal, tp kelunakan dan keunikan tone suara dia. Dan, Irving, for your imformation, barbra ni dulu pelakon broadway dan die pegang leading role, so x heranla kalo suara dia power utk tenggelamkan sore latar. And Irving, Regine nyanyi lagu tu, dia kene potong 3 kali baru part 19s tu |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
Post time 9-3-2006 05:14 PM
